{
  "schema_version": "volmax.battery_evidence_dossier.v0.1",
  "case_id": "sandia",
  "generated_at_utc": "2018-10-28T14:40:53Z",
  "battery_identification": {
    "asset_id": "SNL_18650_NMC_25C_0-100_0.5-2C_a",
    "asset_scope": "single_laboratory_cell",
    "chemistry": "NMC (LiNixMnyCo1-x-yO2)",
    "configuration": "18650 cylindrical cell (LG Chem 18650HG2, 3.0 Ah nominal, 25 C chamber, 0-100% DOD, 0.5C chg / 2.0C dis)",
    "measurement_period": {
      "start_utc": "2018-07-17 10:12:57.019048",
      "end_utc": "2018-10-28 14:40:53.209231",
      "test_duration_hours": 1655.402,
      "recorded_rows": 660,
      "cycle_range": [
        1,
        661
      ]
    },
    "source_provenance": {
      "organization": "Sandia National Laboratories (United States Department of Energy)",
      "publication_title": "Degradation of Commercial Lithium-Ion Cells as a Function of Chemistry and Cycling Conditions",
      "journal": "Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 167 (2020) 120532",
      "doi": "10.1149/1945-7111/abae37",
      "osti_id": 1650174,
      "public_archive": "https://www.batteryarchive.org"
    }
  },
  "measurement_integrity": {
    "sha256_verified": true,
    "source_files": [
      {
        "role": "raw_cycling_csv",
        "path": "data/raw/cell.csv",
        "sha256": "e34c2a5ee32c9922e2def6f387d9ba553c27d07ae5a99452f3b15640b339bfc6",
        "rows": 660
      },
      {
        "role": "source_metadata",
        "path": "data/SOURCE.json",
        "sha256": "f51ebbb0c4e708679e4cf3697b11c764f97499a3f3c80b71e29cdea4e55d4f6c"
      },
      {
        "role": "claim_definition",
        "path": "claim/claim.json",
        "sha256": "0a30a4e80fe185e952627dc1db3cc2a62c8c812cea4c001dc694b32dae86a116"
      }
    ],
    "timestamp_continuity": {
      "table_type": "cycle_summary_per_cycle",
      "strictly_increasing_test_time_s": true,
      "strictly_increasing_start_time": true,
      "total_rows": 660,
      "active_cycling_rows": 655,
      "zero_capacity_rest_rows": 5,
      "zero_capacity_cycles": [
        132,
        265,
        397,
        529,
        661
      ],
      "missing_cycle_indices": [
        133
      ]
    },
    "units": {
      "capacity": "Ah",
      "energy": "Wh",
      "voltage": "V",
      "current": "A",
      "temperature": "degC (nominal 25 C metadata only)"
    },
    "measurement_boundaries": {
      "declared_boundary": "cell_dc_terminals",
      "dc_only": true,
      "ac_pcc_present": false,
      "auxiliary_load_present": false
    },
    "unsupported_or_unknown_fields": [
      "internal_resistance_dcir_ohm (UNAVAILABLE: no pulse resistance / EIS column in cell.csv)",
      "system_ac_rte_percent (UNAVAILABLE: single-cell DC cycling has no PCS, aux load, or AC PCC meter)",
      "rul_cycles (NOT_DEMONSTRATED: ML RUL / conformal UQ excluded from measured cell SoH)",
      "temperature_timeseries_degc (UNAVAILABLE: nominal 25 C chamber metadata only)",
      "eu_dpp_commercial_serial_and_operator_id (UNAVAILABLE: public academic lab cell dataset)"
    ]
  },
  "battery_health": {
    "status": "VERIFIED",
    "claim_id": "BESS-L1-CAPACITY-001",
    "metric": "discharge_capacity_retention",
    "baseline_window": {
      "cycles": [
        10,
        11,
        12,
        13,
        14
      ],
      "capacities_ah": [
        2.832,
        2.825,
        2.818,
        2.812,
        2.806
      ],
      "median_ah": 2.818,
      "voltage_min_v": 1.998,
      "voltage_max_v": 4.2
    },
    "comparison_window": {
      "cycles": [
        100,
        101,
        102,
        103,
        104
      ],
      "capacities_ah": [
        2.61,
        2.609,
        2.608,
        2.607,
        2.606
      ],
      "median_ah": 2.608,
      "voltage_min_v": 1.995,
      "voltage_max_v": 4.2
    },
    "retention_percent": 92.54791,
    "retention_percent_3dp": 92.548,
    "threshold_percent": 95.0,
    "predicate": "retention_percent < 95.0",
    "predicate_result": true,
    "full_trajectory_summary": {
      "total_rows": 660,
      "active_cycling_rows": 655,
      "cycle_4_artifact": {
        "cycle": 4,
        "discharge_capacity_ah": 5.767,
        "charge_capacity_ah": 5.796,
        "discharge_energy_wh": 19.076,
        "min_voltage_v": 1.998,
        "max_voltage_v": 4.2,
        "min_current_a": -6.001
      },
      "outlier_cycles_gt_3_5_ah": [
        {
          "cycle": 4,
          "discharge_capacity_ah": 5.767,
          "charge_capacity_ah": 5.796,
          "discharge_energy_wh": 19.076,
          "min_voltage_v": 1.998,
          "max_voltage_v": 4.2
        },
        {
          "cycle": 137,
          "discharge_capacity_ah": 5.147,
          "charge_capacity_ah": 5.165,
          "discharge_energy_wh": 17.122,
          "min_voltage_v": 1.997,
          "max_voltage_v": 4.2
        },
        {
          "cycle": 269,
          "discharge_capacity_ah": 4.813,
          "charge_capacity_ah": 4.83,
          "discharge_energy_wh": 15.369,
          "min_voltage_v": 1.996,
          "max_voltage_v": 4.2
        },
        {
          "cycle": 401,
          "discharge_capacity_ah": 4.82,
          "charge_capacity_ah": 4.835,
          "discharge_energy_wh": 15.502,
          "min_voltage_v": 1.996,
          "max_voltage_v": 4.2
        },
        {
          "cycle": 533,
          "discharge_capacity_ah": 4.689,
          "charge_capacity_ah": 4.701,
          "discharge_energy_wh": 15.289,
          "min_voltage_v": 1.996,
          "max_voltage_v": 4.2
        }
      ],
      "zero_capacity_rest_cycles": [
        132,
        265,
        397,
        529,
        661
      ]
    },
    "rul_cycles": {
      "status": "NOT_DEMONSTRATED",
      "value": null,
      "reason": "ML RUL and conformal UQ models (Battery_Health_Portfolio, volmax-uq-bess-audit) are trained on LFP/LCO cells and are excluded from measured NMC cell SoH."
    },
    "internal_resistance_dcir": {
      "status": "UNAVAILABLE",
      "value": null,
      "reason": "No DCIR / HPPC pulse measurement column exists in data/raw/cell.csv."
    },
    "protocol_and_limitations": [
      "Single laboratory cylindrical 18650 cell (LG Chem 18650HG2, 3.0 Ah nominal); cannot be scaled directly to pack or plant-level BESS capacity or AC RTE.",
      "Cycle-4 anomalous double-capacity artifact detected: 5.767 Ah discharge (5.796 Ah charge, 1.998-4.200 V); similar ~132-cycle-interval artifacts appear at cycles [4, 137, 269, 401, 533].",
      "Cycle sequence spans [1, 661] across 660 rows: missing cycle indices [133], and 5 rest/pause rows [132, 265, 397, 529, 661] record 0.0 Ah / 0.0 A.",
      "No DCIR / HPPC internal resistance measurements or per-second cell temperature time-series exist in cell.csv.",
      "ML RUL / conformal UQ models (Battery_Health_Portfolio, volmax-uq-bess-audit) are excluded because they are trained on LFP/LCO datasets and lack OOD exchangeability or NMC cell calibration."
    ]
  },
  "operational_performance": {
    "measurement_boundary": "cell_dc_terminals",
    "voltage_envelope_all_rows_v": {
      "min": 1.991,
      "max": 4.229
    },
    "voltage_envelope_baseline_and_cycle4_v": {
      "min": 1.998,
      "max": 4.2
    },
    "current_envelope_a": {
      "min": -6.001,
      "max": 1.5
    },
    "throughput_totals": {
      "total_charge_capacity_ah": 1623.843,
      "total_discharge_capacity_ah": 1625.91,
      "total_charge_energy_wh": 6317.968,
      "total_discharge_energy_wh": 5374.839,
      "gross_cell_dc_wh_ratio_percent": 85.0723,
      "coulombic_ratio_percent": 100.1273
    },
    "system_ac_rte": {
      "status": "UNAVAILABLE",
      "value": null,
      "reason": "Single-cell DC cycling only (gross cell DC Wh ratio = 85.0723%); no inverter/PCS, auxiliary loads, or AC PCC meter exist."
    }
  },
  "evidence_and_conclusions": {
    "epistemic_separation": {
      "observed_facts": [
        "data/raw/cell.csv SHA-256 verified as e34c2a5ee32c9922e2def6f387d9ba553c27d07ae5a99452f3b15640b339bfc6 across 660 rows (cycles 1-661, missing indices [133]).",
        "Baseline cycles [10, 11, 12, 13, 14] discharge capacities: [2.832, 2.825, 2.818, 2.812, 2.806] Ah (V = 1.998-4.200 V).",
        "Comparison cycles [100, 101, 102, 103, 104] discharge capacities: [2.61, 2.609, 2.608, 2.607, 2.606] Ah (V = 1.995-4.200 V).",
        "Cycle 4 records an anomalous 5.767 Ah discharge (V = 1.998-4.200 V, I_min = -6.001 A); 5 double-capacity cycles ([4, 137, 269, 401, 533]) and 5 zero-Ah rest rows ([132, 265, 397, 529, 661]) appear.",
        "Cumulative cell DC throughput across all 660 rows: 6317.9680 Wh charged, 5374.8390 Wh discharged; overall voltage bounds 1.991-4.229 V."
      ],
      "derived_values": [
        "Median baseline discharge capacity (cycles 10-14): 2.8180 Ah.",
        "Median comparison discharge capacity (cycles 100-104): 2.6080 Ah.",
        "Measured capacity retention: 92.548% (exact 92.54791%), satisfying frozen predicate 'retention_percent < 95.0' -> VERIFIED.",
        "Gross cell DC Wh ratio across 660 rows: 85.0723% (cell-terminal DC energy only, not system AC RTE)."
      ],
      "estimates": [
        "No ML RUL, conformal interval, or R_int capability estimates are emitted in this dossier (excluded due to chemistry mismatch, missing DCIR/delta-Q(V) features, and OOD exchangeability limits)."
      ],
      "unsupported_claims": [
        "Claiming single 18650 cell capacity retention represents commercial pack/plant BESS SoH or contractual AC RTE (UNAVAILABLE).",
        "Claiming remaining useful life (RUL) or internal resistance (DCIR) from cell.csv (NOT_DEMONSTRATED / UNAVAILABLE).",
        "Treating cycle-4 (5.767 Ah) or ~132-cycle RPT/cycler reset spikes as true single-cycle reversible cell capacity."
      ]
    },
    "reproduction_command": "python -m dossier_engine.cli build --case sandia --out-dir output",
    "calculation_method_and_version": "bess-evidence-lab-mvp/verifier/verify.py (2dd708e) + sandia_adapter.py v0.1.0",
    "upstream_pins": [
      {
        "repo_name": "VolMax-Studio/bess-evidence-lab-mvp",
        "repo_path": "upstream/bess-evidence-lab-mvp",
        "pinned_commit": "2dd708e",
        "entrypoint": "verifier/verify.py",
        "entrypoint_sha256": "ea1f682429b8f1126509edc936d7bdd3948034ed59e922a67eb0ebbe2873139d"
      }
    ],
    "source_and_calculation_hashes": {
      "calculation_sha256": "cfc93403e4d2a29f08603b0a56155e2279c34963debe7ea41b64d960c1a64f33",
      "verifier_calculation_sha256": "d4d25575c7181c746aefae87a79dfd715e05275d4d210540a8aafa4844793ae8",
      "verifier_self_sha256": "ea1f682429b8f1126509edc936d7bdd3948034ed59e922a67eb0ebbe2873139d",
      "claim_sha256": "0a30a4e80fe185e952627dc1db3cc2a62c8c812cea4c001dc694b32dae86a116",
      "data_sha256": "e34c2a5ee32c9922e2def6f387d9ba553c27d07ae5a99452f3b15640b339bfc6",
      "input_files": [
        {
          "role": "raw_cycling_csv",
          "path": "data/raw/cell.csv",
          "sha256": "e34c2a5ee32c9922e2def6f387d9ba553c27d07ae5a99452f3b15640b339bfc6",
          "rows": 660
        },
        {
          "role": "source_metadata",
          "path": "data/SOURCE.json",
          "sha256": "f51ebbb0c4e708679e4cf3697b11c764f97499a3f3c80b71e29cdea4e55d4f6c"
        },
        {
          "role": "claim_definition",
          "path": "claim/claim.json",
          "sha256": "0a30a4e80fe185e952627dc1db3cc2a62c8c812cea4c001dc694b32dae86a116"
        }
      ]
    }
  },
  "regulatory_mapping": {
    "regulation_reference": "Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 (Article 77, Annex VII, Annex XIII) & Commission Battery Passport Guidance v3.2 (Oct 2026, 71-attribute catalog)",
    "disclaimer": "NOT an EU Digital Battery Passport. Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 (mandatory for EV, LMT, and industrial batteries > 2 kWh from 18 February 2027) places statutory accuracy, completeness, QR/unique-identifier, and EU DPP Registry obligations on the responsible economic operator. This table maps technical parameters (principally Annex VII) to currently verified or unavailable VolMax evidence.",
    "rows": [
      {
        "parameter": "Battery & operator identification / QR / passport link (Annex XIII)",
        "applicability": "Mandatory for EU passport-scoped batteries (> 2 kWh industrial / EV / LMT); N/A to lab 18650 cell",
        "source_data": "data/SOURCE.json (Sandia SNL_18650_NMC_25C_0-100_0.5-2C_a, LG Chem 18650HG2)",
        "volmax_component": "bess-evidence-lab-mvp metadata + asset_attribution guard",
        "verification_status": "DESCRIPTIVE_ONLY",
        "missing_information": "Commercial EU operator ID, batch/serial EU DPP UID, manufacturing plant & CE/conformity declarations",
        "responsible_provider": "Economic Operator / Cell Manufacturer"
      },
      {
        "parameter": "Rated & remaining usable capacity / capacity retention (Annex VII)",
        "applicability": "Applicable technical health parameter (here demonstrated at 18650 lab cell level)",
        "source_data": "data/raw/cell.csv (cycles 10-14 vs 100-104 Discharge_Capacity Ah)",
        "volmax_component": "bess-evidence-lab-mvp/verifier/verify.py (median retention = 92.548%)",
        "verification_status": "VERIFIED",
        "missing_information": "System-level pack/plant scaling, calendar rest protocol, standardized EU capacity-test ambient controls",
        "responsible_provider": "Independent Verifier (telemetry) + Economic Operator (nameplate/protocol)"
      },
      {
        "parameter": "Energy throughput & cycle count history (Annex VII)",
        "applicability": "Applicable technical usage parameter",
        "source_data": "data/raw/cell.csv (Cycle_Index, Charge/Discharge_Energy Wh, Charge/Discharge_Capacity Ah)",
        "volmax_component": "sandia_adapter cycle-log aggregator (660 recorded rows; outlier cycle 4 flagged)",
        "verification_status": "VERIFIED",
        "missing_information": "Verification of cycle-4 raw cycler anomaly (5.767 Ah vs ~2.93 Ah nominal)",
        "responsible_provider": "Independent Verifier + Test Lab"
      },
      {
        "parameter": "Round-trip energy efficiency (RTE) at system AC boundary (Annex VII)",
        "applicability": "Applicable where applicable to stationary / industrial storage",
        "source_data": "Cell-level Wh only; no inverter, auxiliary load, or AC PCC meter",
        "volmax_component": "None (blocked by boundary check)",
        "verification_status": "UNAVAILABLE",
        "missing_information": "System PCS AC, auxiliary loads, PCC metering, standardized RTE test protocol",
        "responsible_provider": "EPC / System Integrator / Economic Operator"
      },
      {
        "parameter": "Internal resistance & power fade (Annex VII)",
        "applicability": "Applicable Annex VII state-of-health indicator",
        "source_data": "No DCIR / HPPC pulse measurement column in cell.csv",
        "volmax_component": "Not executed (experimental resistance models excluded without DCIR telemetry)",
        "verification_status": "UNAVAILABLE",
        "missing_information": "Timestamped pulse-resistance / EIS / DCIR test records",
        "responsible_provider": "Test Lab / BMS / Economic Operator"
      },
      {
        "parameter": "Negative events (deep discharge, extreme T, faults) (Annex VII)",
        "applicability": "Applicable lifecycle event log",
        "source_data": "Min/Max cell voltage (1.998-4.200 V) in cell.csv; nominal 25 C chamber metadata only",
        "volmax_component": "sandia_adapter voltage-bound check (flags cycle-4 5.767 Ah artifact & V_min=1.998 V)",
        "verification_status": "DESCRIPTIVE_ONLY",
        "missing_information": "Per-second temperature time-series, BMS fault/alarm registers",
        "responsible_provider": "Economic Operator / BMS Owner"
      },
      {
        "parameter": "Remaining useful life (RUL) estimate",
        "applicability": "Supporting lifecycle indicator (not a measured physical constant)",
        "source_data": "Single cell trajectory only; no validated target-population conformal calibration",
        "volmax_component": "volmax-uq-bess-audit (EXCLUDED as experimental for single-cell dossier)",
        "verification_status": "NOT_DEMONSTRATED",
        "missing_information": "Validated population calibration & target operating-profile equivalence",
        "responsible_provider": "Independent Verifier / Modeling Team (if validated)"
      }
    ]
  },
  "charts": [
    {
      "filename": "sandia_capacity_retention.png",
      "path": "sandia_capacity_retention.png",
      "title": "Sandia 18650 NMC Discharge Capacity & Retention Audit (660 Rows)",
      "caption": "Measured discharge capacity across cycles 1-661 showing baseline (10-14, 2.8180 Ah), comparison (100-104, 2.6080 Ah, retention 92.548%), and the cycle-4 5.767 Ah outlier artifact."
    }
  ]
}
