{
  "schema_version": "volmax.battery_evidence_dossier.v0.1",
  "case_id": "enw",
  "generated_at_utc": "2026-09-25T00:00:00Z",
  "battery_identification": {
    "asset_id": "ENW",
    "asset_scope": "grid_scale_bess_anonymized_telemetry",
    "chemistry": "UNAVAILABLE (anonymized in PNNL/EPRI Zenodo release)",
    "configuration": {
      "site_code": "ENW",
      "meters_present": [
        "PAC",
        "PAUX",
        "PDC",
        "PGCP"
      ],
      "rated_kwh": "UNAVAILABLE (normalized to C-rate in published feather)",
      "rated_kw": "UNAVAILABLE",
      "serial_or_oem_identity": "UNAVAILABLE"
    },
    "measurement_period": {
      "time_axis": "HoursElapsed (relative; calendar UTC timestamps withheld in Zenodo release)",
      "sampling_step_s": 60.0,
      "timestamps_per_meter": 85858,
      "duration_hours": 1430.95,
      "duration_days": 59.62
    },
    "source_provenance": {
      "dataset_name": "Grid-Scale BESS Operational Datasets for Battery Modeling Research (ENW subset)",
      "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.22947521",
      "record_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/22947521",
      "publication_date": "2026-09-25",
      "creators": [
        "Crawford, Alasdair",
        "Thompson, Joe"
      ],
      "license": "CC-BY-4.0",
      "r_generation_scripts_inspected": [
        "ENW.R",
        "_common.R"
      ]
    }
  },
  "measurement_integrity": {
    "sha256_verified": true,
    "source_files": [
      {
        "filename": "ENW.feather",
        "path": "data/enw/ENW.feather",
        "sha256": "99dea934c5bfbf1fd6c88365275b41194351eae5a9ccb899b863bb2f75cad943",
        "md5": "d2d58c153d6674ce8ef8242e497dd9b1",
        "size_bytes": 6897434
      },
      {
        "filename": "source_manifest.json",
        "path": "upstream/bess-field-evidence/enw-pnnl-epri/source_manifest.json",
        "sha256": "d88052b29852ed6331ae3ee3562478e50b3161feb2513f22095f307dba143e68",
        "size_bytes": 1444
      }
    ],
    "timestamp_continuity": {
      "expected_step_s": 60.0,
      "total_timestamps_per_meter": 85858,
      "total_gaps": 0,
      "total_duplicates": 0,
      "per_meter": {
        "PAC": {
          "count": 85858,
          "step_s": 60.0,
          "duplicates": 0,
          "gaps": 0
        },
        "PAUX": {
          "count": 85858,
          "step_s": 60.0,
          "duplicates": 0,
          "gaps": 0
        },
        "PDC": {
          "count": 85858,
          "step_s": 60.0,
          "duplicates": 0,
          "gaps": 0
        },
        "PGCP": {
          "count": 85858,
          "step_s": 60.0,
          "duplicates": 0,
          "gaps": 0
        }
      }
    },
    "units": {
      "power": "C-rate_normalized (NOT physical kW; energy sums are normalized C-rate-hours, NOT kWh/MWh)",
      "soc": "fraction [0, 1] (observed 0.0476 to 0.9550; start 0.1580, end 0.9200)",
      "voltage": "V/cell or unscaled per ENW.R (NA when dc_v == 0)",
      "time": "HoursElapsed (hours from series start; 60.0 s uniform spacing)"
    },
    "measurement_boundaries": {
      "PDC": "Battery DC bus (valid intervals only: 70,105 min; NA when dc_v == 0)",
      "PAC": "Inverter AC terminal (full 85,858 min; 0.0 during 15,753 dc_v == 0 min)",
      "PAUX": "Auxiliary load meter (full 85,858 min; positive = consumption)",
      "PGCP": "Grid connection point (full 85,858 min; records -PAUX standby import when dc_v == 0)"
    },
    "quality_flag_decomposition": {
      "any_meter_flagged_min": 15855,
      "unflagged_min": 70003,
      "disconnected_dc_min": 15753,
      "averaged_duplicate_min": 98,
      "idle_soc_jump_min": 4,
      "idle_soc_jump_events": [
        {
          "start_step_index": 4021,
          "hours_elapsed": 67.016667,
          "soc_before": 0.21155,
          "soc_after": 0.837,
          "abs_delta_soc": 0.62545
        },
        {
          "start_step_index": 34092,
          "hours_elapsed": 568.2,
          "soc_before": 0.386083,
          "soc_after": 0.955,
          "abs_delta_soc": 0.568917
        }
      ],
      "disconnected_dc_pac_max_abs": 0.0,
      "disconnected_dc_pgcp_plus_paux_max_abs": 0.001227,
      "disconnected_dc_pgcp_plus_paux_mean": 2.7e-05
    },
    "unsupported_or_unknown_fields": [
      "rated_kwh (UNAVAILABLE — power normalized to C-rate)",
      "rated_kw (UNAVAILABLE)",
      "serial_number / OEM / battery_chemistry (UNAVAILABLE — anonymized site code ENW)",
      "calendar_utc_timestamps (UNAVAILABLE — relative HoursElapsed only)",
      "verified_contractual_rte (NOT_DEMONSTRATED — unclosed SoC 15.8% -> 92.0%, no contract boundary/protocol)",
      "physical_ah_capacity_soh (UNAVAILABLE — no RPT or unnormalized Ah/kWh)"
    ]
  },
  "battery_health": {
    "status": "UNAVAILABLE",
    "measured_capacity_retention_pct": "UNAVAILABLE",
    "internal_resistance_dcir": "UNAVAILABLE",
    "remaining_useful_life": "NOT_DEMONSTRATED",
    "soc_span_pct": {
      "start_pct": 15.8,
      "end_pct": 92.0,
      "min_pct": 4.76,
      "max_pct": 95.5,
      "net_delta_pp": 76.2
    },
    "idle_soc_jump_anomalies": {
      "count": 2,
      "flagged_rows": 4,
      "events": [
        {
          "start_step_index": 4021,
          "hours_elapsed": 67.016667,
          "soc_before": 0.21155,
          "soc_after": 0.837,
          "abs_delta_soc": 0.62545
        },
        {
          "start_step_index": 34092,
          "hours_elapsed": 568.2,
          "soc_before": 0.386083,
          "soc_after": 0.955,
          "abs_delta_soc": 0.568917
        }
      ]
    },
    "protocol_and_limitations": [
      "ENW is strictly separate from Sandia Case A (18650 lab cell); no cross-asset metrics are combined.",
      "Rated kWh/kW, OEM identity, serial number, chemistry, and calendar UTC timestamps are UNAVAILABLE in the anonymized Zenodo release.",
      "System SoC shifts from 15.8% at start to 92.0% at end (+76.2 pp) and exhibits 2 idle SOC_JUMP events (>0.20 jump at <0.005 C), precluding both SoH estimation and contractual RTE certification.",
      "None of the five exported/imported energy ratios (74.5% to 88.9%) is a verified contractual RTE or SAT verdict."
    ]
  },
  "operational_performance": {
    "status": "DESCRIPTIVE_ONLY",
    "verified_rte_status": "NOT_DEMONSTRATED",
    "five_ratios": [
      {
        "key": "pdc_valid_dc",
        "label": "Battery DC (PDC) - valid DC intervals only",
        "intervals_min": 70105,
        "exported_norm": 20.85275,
        "imported_norm": 23.46562,
        "ratio_pct_1dp": 88.9,
        "ratio_pct_3dp": 88.865,
        "ratio_pct_exact": 88.865117
      },
      {
        "key": "pac_full",
        "label": "Inverter AC (PAC) - full observation period",
        "intervals_min": 85858,
        "exported_norm": 20.426401,
        "imported_norm": 24.835948,
        "ratio_pct_1dp": 82.2,
        "ratio_pct_3dp": 82.245,
        "ratio_pct_exact": 82.245306
      },
      {
        "key": "pgcp_full",
        "label": "Grid connection (PGCP) - full observation period",
        "intervals_min": 85858,
        "exported_norm": 19.950685,
        "imported_norm": 26.784368,
        "ratio_pct_1dp": 74.5,
        "ratio_pct_3dp": 74.486,
        "ratio_pct_exact": 74.4863
      },
      {
        "key": "pgcp_unflagged",
        "label": "Grid connection (PGCP) - excl. quality-flagged rows",
        "intervals_min": 70003,
        "exported_norm": 19.924015,
        "imported_norm": 26.374753,
        "ratio_pct_1dp": 75.5,
        "ratio_pct_3dp": 75.542,
        "ratio_pct_exact": 75.541997
      },
      {
        "key": "pgcp_use",
        "label": "Grid connection (PGCP) - authors' \"Use\" segments",
        "intervals_min": 19487,
        "exported_norm": 18.651774,
        "imported_norm": 23.378622,
        "ratio_pct_1dp": 79.8,
        "ratio_pct_3dp": 79.781,
        "ratio_pct_exact": 79.781322
      }
    ],
    "ratios_by_key": {
      "pdc_valid_dc": {
        "key": "pdc_valid_dc",
        "label": "Battery DC (PDC) - valid DC intervals only",
        "intervals_min": 70105,
        "exported_norm": 20.85275,
        "imported_norm": 23.46562,
        "ratio_pct_1dp": 88.9,
        "ratio_pct_3dp": 88.865,
        "ratio_pct_exact": 88.865117
      },
      "pac_full": {
        "key": "pac_full",
        "label": "Inverter AC (PAC) - full observation period",
        "intervals_min": 85858,
        "exported_norm": 20.426401,
        "imported_norm": 24.835948,
        "ratio_pct_1dp": 82.2,
        "ratio_pct_3dp": 82.245,
        "ratio_pct_exact": 82.245306
      },
      "pgcp_full": {
        "key": "pgcp_full",
        "label": "Grid connection (PGCP) - full observation period",
        "intervals_min": 85858,
        "exported_norm": 19.950685,
        "imported_norm": 26.784368,
        "ratio_pct_1dp": 74.5,
        "ratio_pct_3dp": 74.486,
        "ratio_pct_exact": 74.4863
      },
      "pgcp_unflagged": {
        "key": "pgcp_unflagged",
        "label": "Grid connection (PGCP) - excl. quality-flagged rows",
        "intervals_min": 70003,
        "exported_norm": 19.924015,
        "imported_norm": 26.374753,
        "ratio_pct_1dp": 75.5,
        "ratio_pct_3dp": 75.542,
        "ratio_pct_exact": 75.541997
      },
      "pgcp_use": {
        "key": "pgcp_use",
        "label": "Grid connection (PGCP) - authors' \"Use\" segments",
        "intervals_min": 19487,
        "exported_norm": 18.651774,
        "imported_norm": 23.378622,
        "ratio_pct_1dp": 79.8,
        "ratio_pct_3dp": 79.781,
        "ratio_pct_exact": 79.781322
      }
    },
    "common_valid_dc_isolation": {
      "common_window_min": 70105,
      "disconnected_dc_min": 15753,
      "flagged_in_common_valid_dc_min": 102,
      "pdc_common_pct": 88.865117,
      "pac_common_pct": 82.245306,
      "pgcp_common_pct": 75.606516,
      "pgcp_full_pct": 74.4863,
      "pure_boundary_shift_pp": 13.258601,
      "window_extension_shift_pp": -1.120216
    },
    "quality_flag_decomposition": {
      "any_meter_flagged_min": 15855,
      "unflagged_min": 70003,
      "disconnected_dc_min": 15753,
      "averaged_duplicate_min": 98,
      "idle_soc_jump_min": 4,
      "idle_soc_jump_events": [
        {
          "start_step_index": 4021,
          "hours_elapsed": 67.016667,
          "soc_before": 0.21155,
          "soc_after": 0.837,
          "abs_delta_soc": 0.62545
        },
        {
          "start_step_index": 34092,
          "hours_elapsed": 568.2,
          "soc_before": 0.386083,
          "soc_after": 0.955,
          "abs_delta_soc": 0.568917
        }
      ],
      "disconnected_dc_pac_max_abs": 0.0,
      "disconnected_dc_pgcp_plus_paux_max_abs": 0.001227,
      "disconnected_dc_pgcp_plus_paux_mean": 2.7e-05
    },
    "paux_consumption": {
      "total_norm_energy": 2.37037,
      "flagged_rows_norm_energy": 0.406847,
      "flagged_rows_pct": 17.16,
      "disconnected_dc_norm_energy": 0.403938,
      "disconnected_dc_pct": 17.04,
      "min_power_c_rate": 0.001129,
      "max_power_c_rate": 0.002119
    },
    "cycle_segmentation": {
      "total_segments": 214,
      "use_segments": 65,
      "use_intervals_min": 19487
    },
    "soc_summary": {
      "start_fraction": 0.158,
      "end_fraction": 0.92,
      "start_pct": 15.8,
      "end_pct": 92.0,
      "min_pct": 4.76,
      "max_pct": 95.5,
      "net_delta_pp": 76.2
    }
  },
  "evidence_and_conclusions": {
    "summary": "Independent reproduction of the PNNL/EPRI ENW 1-minute field dataset (85,858 timestamps/meter at exact 60.0 s, 0 gaps) demonstrates five distinct descriptive exported/imported energy ratios spanning 74.486% (74.5%) to 88.865% (88.9%). Evaluating PGCP and PDC on the common 70,105-minute valid-DC timestamp set isolates a +13.259 pp descriptive boundary shift (75.607% -> 88.865%), separate from the -1.120 pp window-extension shift (75.607% -> 74.486%) caused by adding 15,753 disconnected-DC standby minutes (dc_v == 0, PAC == 0, PGCP ~= -PAUX). Because SoC rises from 15.8% to 92.0% and power is C-rate normalized without rated kWh or contract rules, verified contractual RTE is NOT_DEMONSTRATED.",
    "epistemic_separation": {
      "observed_facts": [
        "ENW.feather matches pinned Zenodo SHA-256 (99dea934c5bfbf1fd6c88365275b41194351eae5a9ccb899b863bb2f75cad943) and MD5 (d2d58c153d6674ce8ef8242e497dd9b1).",
        "All 4 meters (PAC, PAUX, PDC, PGCP) contain 85,858 uniform 60.0 s timestamps (0 gaps, 0 duplicates; 59.62 days).",
        "System SoC starts at 15.8% (0.158) and ends at 92.0% (0.920), spanning 4.76% to 95.50% overall.",
        "QualityFlag marks 15,855 any-meter timestamps: 15,753 disconnected DC (dc_v == 0, where PAC == 0.0 and max |PGCP + PAUX| = 0.001227), 98 averaged duplicate timestamps, and 4 idle SOC_JUMP rows (2 events).",
        "Normalized PAUX totals 2.3704 units, with 0.4068 units (17.16%) consumed during QualityFlag=True timestamps (17.04% during dc_v == 0)."
      ],
      "derived_values": [
        "PDC valid DC intervals (70,105 min): exported/imported ratio = 88.865% (88.9%).",
        "PAC full observation period (85,858 min): exported/imported ratio = 82.245% (82.2%).",
        "PGCP full observation period (85,858 min): exported/imported ratio = 74.486% (74.5%).",
        "PGCP excluding any QualityFlag (70,003 min): exported/imported ratio = 75.542% (75.5%).",
        "PGCP authors' Use=True segments (65 of 214 segments, 19,487 min): exported/imported ratio = 79.781% (79.8%).",
        "Common 70,105-min valid-DC timestamp set (incl. 102 flagged rows): PGCP 75.607% -> PAC 82.245% -> PDC 88.865% (+13.259 pp boundary ratio shift); extending PGCP to 85,858 min shifts 75.607% -> 74.486% (-1.120 pp)."
      ],
      "estimates": [
        "None — no ML/parametric SoH, RUL, or unmeasured loss attribution model is executed on ENW."
      ],
      "unsupported_claims": [
        "Claiming any of the five ratios (74.5% to 88.9%) is a verified contractual round-trip efficiency (RTE) without SoC closure (delta SoC = +76.2 pp) and contractual boundary terms.",
        "Treating +13.259 pp boundary ratio shift as direct causal component-loss attribution (inverter vs transformer vs auxiliaries).",
        "Converting normalized C-rate energy sums to physical kWh/MWh or attributing ENW telemetry to Sandia Case A."
      ]
    },
    "reproduction_command": "python -m dossier_engine.cli build --case enw --out-dir output",
    "calculation_method_and_version": {
      "adapter": "dossier_engine.adapters.enw_adapter.build_enw_case",
      "adapter_version": "0.1.0",
      "upstream_entrypoint": "VolMax-Studio/bess-field-evidence/enw-pnnl-epri/reproduce.py@833c467",
      "integration_method": "Uniform 60.0 s rectangular integration (dt = 1/60 h) via reproduce.energy_ratio"
    },
    "upstream_pins": [
      {
        "repo_name": "VolMax-Studio/bess-field-evidence",
        "repo_path": "upstream/bess-field-evidence",
        "pinned_commit": "833c467",
        "entrypoint": "enw-pnnl-epri/reproduce.py",
        "entrypoint_sha256": "63b1acf311ccf46534268e2d2abbff0ae43090f07d7179c7e630da69989f3c23"
      }
    ],
    "source_and_calculation_hashes": {
      "calculation_sha256": "1907de2c8c86ff9db870b1ad64cc37d962c9892b1e4a829f2a0f5acd78b79619",
      "input_files": [
        {
          "path": "data/enw/ENW.feather",
          "sha256": "99dea934c5bfbf1fd6c88365275b41194351eae5a9ccb899b863bb2f75cad943",
          "md5": "d2d58c153d6674ce8ef8242e497dd9b1"
        },
        {
          "path": "upstream/bess-field-evidence/enw-pnnl-epri/source_manifest.json",
          "sha256": "d88052b29852ed6331ae3ee3562478e50b3161feb2513f22095f307dba143e68"
        }
      ]
    }
  },
  "regulatory_mapping": {
    "regulation_reference": "Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 (Article 77, Annex VII, Annex XIII) & Commission Battery Passport Guidance v3.2 (Oct 2026, 71-attribute catalog)",
    "disclaimer": "NOT an EU Digital Battery Passport. Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 (mandatory for EV, LMT, and industrial batteries > 2 kWh from 18 February 2027) places statutory accuracy, completeness, QR/unique-identifier, and EU DPP Registry obligations on the responsible economic operator. This table maps technical parameters (principally Annex VII) to currently verified or unavailable VolMax evidence.",
    "rows": [
      {
        "parameter": "Battery & operator identification / QR / passport link (Annex XIII)",
        "applicability": "Mandatory for EU industrial BESS > 2 kWh placed on EU market from 2027-02-18",
        "source_data": "Zenodo DOI 10.5281/zenodo.22947521 (site code ENW anonymized: no serial, kWh rating, or calendar UTC)",
        "volmax_component": "enw_adapter source_manifest.json hash check",
        "verification_status": "UNAVAILABLE",
        "missing_information": "Asset rated MWh/MW, OEM/integrator ID, serial numbers, EU operator registration",
        "responsible_provider": "Economic Operator / Asset Owner"
      },
      {
        "parameter": "Round-trip energy efficiency (RTE) & energy ratios (Annex VII)",
        "applicability": "Applicable where possible to stationary industrial BESS",
        "source_data": "ENW.feather (PDC, PAC, PAUX, PGCP normalized to C-rate; SOC 15.8% -> 92.0%)",
        "volmax_component": "bess-field-evidence/enw-pnnl-epri/reproduce.py (5 ratios + 70,105-min common timestamp check)",
        "verification_status": "NOT_DEMONSTRATED",
        "missing_information": "SoC closure (delta SoC != 0), contractual boundary/auxiliary definition, unnormalized kWh",
        "responsible_provider": "Owner's Engineer + Economic Operator (contract terms) + Verifier"
      },
      {
        "parameter": "Energy throughput & operating segments (Annex VII)",
        "applicability": "Applicable operational usage indicator",
        "source_data": "ENW.feather (85,858 min at 60 s; CycleIndex 214 segments, Use=True 65 segments)",
        "volmax_component": "bess-field-evidence/enw-pnnl-epri/reproduce.py (normalized export/import sums)",
        "verification_status": "DESCRIPTIVE_ONLY",
        "missing_information": "Rated kWh scaling factor to convert normalized C-rate hours into physical MWh",
        "responsible_provider": "Economic Operator (rated capacity specification)"
      },
      {
        "parameter": "Remaining usable capacity / SoH (%) (Annex VII)",
        "applicability": "Mandatory dynamic parameter in Annex VII",
        "source_data": "SOC column has idle jumps (max |dSOC|=0.625) and no reference capacity test kWh",
        "volmax_component": "None (not inferred from operational C-rate without capacity test)",
        "verification_status": "UNAVAILABLE",
        "missing_information": "Unnormalized reference performance test (RPT) discharge capacity in Ah/kWh",
        "responsible_provider": "Economic Operator / Commissioning Test Team"
      },
      {
        "parameter": "Power capability & auxiliary load accounting (Annex VII)",
        "applicability": "Applicable technical capability & boundary record",
        "source_data": "PAUX (2.3704 norm. units, 17.16% during QualityFlag=True) & PGCP/PAC/PDC",
        "volmax_component": "enw_adapter meter balance & disconnected-DC standby accounting",
        "verification_status": "DESCRIPTIVE_ONLY",
        "missing_information": "Physical kW nameplate & thermal-derating test envelope",
        "responsible_provider": "Economic Operator / EPC"
      },
      {
        "parameter": "Negative events & data-quality anomalies (Annex VII)",
        "applicability": "Applicable operational integrity indicator",
        "source_data": "QualityFlag (15,855 timestamps: 15,753 dc_v==0, 98 averaged duplicates, 4 idle SOC_JUMP)",
        "volmax_component": "enw_adapter + _common.R flag decomposition",
        "verification_status": "VERIFIED",
        "missing_information": "Root-cause maintenance logs explaining why DC was disconnected for 15,753 min",
        "responsible_provider": "Asset Operator / O&M Provider"
      }
    ]
  },
  "charts": [
    {
      "path": "enw_five_ratios.png",
      "title": "ENW Five Descriptive Energy Ratios & Common-Timestamp Isolation",
      "caption": "Comparison of all five descriptive exported/imported ratios (74.5% to 88.9%) plus the 70,105-min common valid-DC set isolating boundary shift (+13.259 pp) from standby extension (-1.120 pp)."
    },
    {
      "path": "enw_telemetry_overview.png",
      "title": "ENW Telemetry Overview: SoC, Power Envelope, QualityFlags & PAUX",
      "caption": "59.62-day trajectory showing unclosed SoC (15.8% -> 92.0%, 2 idle SOC_JUMP events), PGCP/PAUX power envelopes with dc_v==0 standby shading, and 15,855 QualityFlag breakdown."
    }
  ]
}
